R1.3.2 Incomplete combustion

Incomplete Combustion of Organic Compounds

What Is Incomplete Combustion?

As discussed in the previous section, combustion is a chemical reaction where a fuel reacts with oxygen, releasing energy in the form of heat or light.
In an ideal scenario, known as complete combustion, hydrocarbons (organic compounds made of carbon and hydrogen) burn in the presence of sufficient oxygen to produce carbon dioxide $C O_{2}$ and water $H_{2} O$ .
However, when oxygen is in short supply, incomplete combustion occurs.
Instead of forming only carbon dioxide and water, incomplete combustion produces harmful byproducts like carbon monoxide $C O$ and elemental carbon $C$ , commonly observed as soot.

General Equations for Incomplete Combustion:

Formation of carbon monoxide:
$Fuel + O_{2} \to CO + H_{2} O$
Formation of carbon (soot):
$Fuel + O_{2} \to C + H_{2} O$

Example

Formation of carbon monoxide:
$2 {CH}_{4} + 3 O_{2} \to 2 CO + 4 H_{2} O$
Formation of soot:
${CH}_{4} + O_{2} \to C + 2 H_{2} O$

Note

Incomplete combustion typically occurs in environments where oxygen is limited, such as car engines, poorly ventilated homes, or industrial furnaces.

Why Does Incomplete Combustion Occur?

Incomplete combustion happens when oxygen becomes the limiting reactant in the reaction. Several factors can contribute to this:

Poor ventilation:
- In confined or poorly ventilated spaces, oxygen levels may drop below the threshold needed for complete combustion.
Fuel composition:
- Larger hydrocarbons, with longer and more complex carbon chains, require more oxygen to burn completely and are therefore more prone to incomplete combustion.
Combustion conditions:
- Low temperatures or insufficient mixing of fuel and oxygen can hinder complete combustion.

Analogy

Think of combustion like following a recipe. If you don’t have enough of a key ingredient—like eggs in baking—you’ll end up with an incomplete or flawed final product. In combustion, oxygen is that essential ingredient.

Products of Incomplete Combustion

1. Carbon Monoxide (CO):

Carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless, and highly toxic gas.
It forms when carbon atoms in the fuel are only partially oxidized due to insufficient oxygen.

Why Is Carbon Monoxide Dangerous?

Carbon monoxide binds tightly and irreversibly to hemoglobin in the blood, forming carboxyhemoglobin.
This reduces the ability of blood to carry oxygen, leading to symptoms like dizziness, nausea, and, in severe cases, death.

Common Mistake

Students often mistakenly believe that carbon monoxide is "less harmful" than carbon dioxide because it has fewer oxygen atoms. In reality, carbon monoxide is far more dangerous due to its ability to disrupt oxygen transport in the body.

2. Soot (Elemental Carbon, C):

Soot consists of fine black particles of carbon that result from incomplete combustion.
These particles can settle on surfaces (like the pot over your campfire) or remain suspended in the air as particulate matter.

Health and Environmental Impacts of Soot:

Health risks:
- Inhalation of soot particles can irritate the respiratory system, leading to asthma, bronchitis, and long-term lung damage.
- Chronic exposure is linked to cardiovascular diseases and cancer.
Environmental impact:
- Soot contributes to air pollution and accelerates the melting of ice and snow when it settles on their surfaces, reducing their reflectivity.

Example

In rural areas where wood or coal is commonly used for cooking, incomplete combustion in poorly ventilated kitchens can lead to dangerous levels of indoor air pollution, significantly affecting the health of household members.

Consequences of Incomplete Combustion

1. Health Hazards:

Incomplete combustion produces harmful substances like carbon monoxide and particulate matter, which pose serious health risks:

Carbon monoxide poisoning: Even at low concentrations, CO can impair oxygen delivery to the body's tissues, causing hypoxia.
Respiratory issues: Soot particles can irritate the respiratory tract, causing coughing, wheezing, and long-term lung damage.

Self review

What are the two main harmful products of incomplete combustion, and how do they affect human health?

2. Environmental Impacts:

Incomplete combustion contributes to:

Air pollution: Soot and other particulates reduce air quality and visibility.
Global warming: Soot particles absorb sunlight, contributing to atmospheric warming.
Acid rain: Incomplete combustion of fuels containing sulfur or nitrogen can release sulfur dioxide $S O_{2}$ or nitrogen oxides $N O_{x}$ , which react with water in the atmosphere to form acids.

3. Energy Inefficiency:

Incomplete combustion is less efficient than complete combustion, as it releases less energy.
This inefficiency means that fuel is wasted, leading to higher costs and more emissions.

Tip

To improve energy efficiency and reduce harmful emissions, ensure that combustion systems—such as car engines, stoves, and furnaces—are well-maintained and properly ventilated.

How to Identify Incomplete Combustion

You can recognize incomplete combustion through:

Visual clues: Black soot deposits on surfaces or a yellow/orange flame (as opposed to a blue flame, which indicates complete combustion).
Odor: A strong, unpleasant smell from unburned hydrocarbons or other byproducts.
Health symptoms: Headaches, dizziness, or nausea in enclosed spaces may indicate carbon monoxide exposure.

Reflection

Theory of Knowledge

How does the need to reduce incomplete combustion influence the development of cleaner technologies? What ethical considerations arise when balancing economic development with environmental and health impacts?

You've read 2/2 free chapters this week.

Upgrade to PLUS or PRO to unlock all notes, for every subject.